The standard size 1911 is the smallest of the three pens in length. Found insideHe is a fourth-generation sailor, a rabid fisherman, a pilot, a surfer, and a frequent traveler to the remote and exotic places of the world, having become addicted to National Geographic magazine as a platinum, or multiplatinum. I don't know if there is a way to find local FPN members who would be nearby. Platinum. The C74 can use a CON-70 converter with greater ink capacity than most and the Platinum converters are by far my favorite of any for their design and ease of cleaning(no glued threads). When you first writing with them you think "WTH" because they don't feel like most other nibs, but then after a few pages and the more you write, the deeper and stronger the magic spell starts to weave. Some do not have a second metal band on one end. (Pilot vs Sailor vs Platinum) Advice. I've read the 3776 is fussyany idea what to pick? The Pilot has a smaller nib, but it's more ornate. Never had a problem with the 3776, maybe I'm just lucky? I'm a FP user in Australia. Platinum. My Sailors and Nakayas live uninked inside the storage box. You may only feel some resistance, but very soon, the ink supply to the tip dries up entirely and you are left with white grooves instead of lines. I would say my Pilots feel almost muffled like theres something absorbing vibrations in the body. Any titling to one side results in the nib catching on the paper, but this is far from unpleasant and is actually something that makes it unique compared with other brands. I find their pens too small unless one goes for the Izumo. Spencerian Customization - Frequently Asked Questions 1. The Pilot gold EFs seem to be a LITTLE softer and have a slightly wider sweet spot. Have not only the most variability in their design compared to the other 2, but also in their consistency. My Sailor doesn't dry out - not at all. Jumping to a gold nib, the first thing people want is an elevated and smooth writing experience. The logo mark and logotype will be renewed. The nib has much longer tines, which makes it a lot softer. It's probably the broadest M from the Pilot range I have. Sailor 1911 Black Luster. And jar I appreciate your matter of fact even-keeled statement that I know is based on your subjective experience with a variety (wide, I think) of this realm of pens. I remember reading one account of a fellow maybe here or elsewhere who claimed that he bought 3 Sailors, one after the other, and each one he described as being "unusable" and, thus, promptly sent it off to Pendleton Brown to have it 'fixed'. I have not found enough difference between any of the nibs from the Japanese brands to prefer one over the others. Platinum: Sterling Silver; Izumo; President Tagayasan Higo Zogan Briar Kanazawa . Although this does vary this is usually around 0.6mm in width. In turn, pens from these manufacturers can only utilize their own proprietary ink cartridges--with the exception of Nakaya/Platinum, which offers an adapter (available from us at a . I've had nothing but good experiences with Platinum pens, at least those that come aligned with well-shaped tipping (but the chance of a dud is there with all pens). NAMED ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS OF THE YEAR BY NPR Tordotcom Kirkus Reviews A soldier with a curse Tala lost her family to the empresss army and has spent her life avenging them in battle. Most have probably found it long ago, but here's a link, anyway: I read your blog post and all the replies with much interest. Something that would appeal to a person use to nice western fountain pens. Current Daily Carry: Pilot Custom 743 with 14k Posting nib (Sailor Kiwa-Guro), Sailor 1911L Realo Champagne with 21k Extra Fine nib (Sailor Tokiwa-Matsu). Yes, the Platinum nib is toothy, but I do not much object to the tooth, as I find it keeps the pen in control. Found inside Page 50vs. Proprietary. Nibs aren't the only things that manufacturers make themselves. Some make their pens specifically so A few prolific companies that require proprietary cartridges and converters are Lamy, Pilot, Platinum, and Sailor. The benefit of cartridges is the convenience, however, they are not nearly as That said I only have the 3776 with the SF nib that just is not doing it for me right now. One of my friends was curious about Platinum Carbon Black vs Kiwaguro Black, so I put these reviews back-to-back. On copy paper, almost all of the inks performed well, with little to no smearing. I like them all which can be very frustrating for the budget! Assuming pens are of equal wetness - Pilot tends to be the smoothest (though arguably "less interesting" as a result.) It is the largest pen manufacturer in Japan, with competition globally from other pen companies like Japanese Pentel Co . Powered by Invision Community, I hope you enjoy it You are so very lucky , Not sure if this has been suggested already but would a setting for localized regions or chapters in FPN be helpful? I'm not sure what's meant be "better" here, but the KoP isn't really better than the lower down Sailors, just different. Hi again all, Pilot: Platinum* Sailor *The Platinum Preppy and Plaisir are exceptions. Sailor branded cartridge/converter. Its kinda redundant. This despite me finding the C74 better balanced and more restrainedly designed than the 3776. While this sounds like the minimum expected of any round-tipped pen, it is more than can be said for the Pilots I have owned. Sailor pens. Found inside Page 82YOU CAN OWN A READY MADE OR DO YOU WANT TO TRAVEL AT OUR Our handbook on Few opportunities so prof- gold , platinum or silver jewelry , new or Open The pen has a pattern that . They fit my small hand & sport excellent nibs. I prefer fine nibs with western and Japanese and they are about as broad or fine as I like to go overall, and I can work with ef western nibs in between that. My recent experience in using my Platinum President Demonstrator pen, may have elevated Platinum to the top of these three Japanese pen manufacturers. A 74 SFM nib on steroids maybe if that is possible. The writing point of these nibs is approximately 0.8mm in width. The 1911 Large is more of the size of the 3776 Century. When that is the question the answer becomes simple; "Buy whichever is first available in the color and nib combination that strikes your fancy at a price you think reasonable.". And their Blue-Black ink is one of my favourites. Both are famed, classic cigar-style pens. Here is a video comparison covering the differences and commonalities. My Sailor EFs feel very similar to Pilot EFs. After my Sailor Pro Gear, this is always inked up and ready to go. They are softer and generally wetter than Platinum and Sailor. I keep reading things like this about their nibs & my curiosity is piqued. I do have a Sailor 1911S and a couple of Platinum Century 3776s. Beautiful fountain pen ink colors in bottles, cartridges, and samples. and am looking for a fancier pen than the TWSBIs I have right now. "M" -0.7 mm.BLS, (PB). All from a HK reseller. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Some people will say 21k nibs are smoother while some people say that 14k nibs are smoother, so there isn't really any pattern or rationale for there to be any difference. I've tried all three brands - Pilot, Sailor and Platinum - over a decade and in the end I prefer Pilot. The sfm nib in my limited experience is quite a sweet spot in Pilot's gold nib collection. I bought my first Sailor shortly after. This is a direct competitor to the Sailor 1911 and the Pilot Custom 74. They're billed as disposable because at that price, you can toss each one as it runs dry, but Platinum is quick to point out that refills are available (and you can get a nine-color set of extra cartridges). How wet the nib is has a BIG effect on how smooth the pen feels and thats somewhat unpredictable. Other brands make the lines a bit more distinct. Medium (M) is the most popular nib width. It might help if we knew what your definition of "best" is and what nib width you are are thinking about. Platinum offers a wide range of nib options for this pen. Found inside Page 120Nowadays, this method is still implemented in the production of pens of such brands as Pilot-Namiki, Sailor or Nakaya, which consciously refer to its ancient origin. Similarly, Platinum in Tokyo uses in its Yaku-Sugi series wood from I agree! Depending on the color of the resin, the trims are either gold or silver (rhodium). El-basguitarskole. Platinum pens. Despite a local nibmeister's best attempts to modify the nibs to my liking, it has been impossible to remedy this problem, resulting in my needing to sell off both my Pilots in frustration. That might help narrow down the selection. I don't know if this still can be changed - if not, I am a bit dissapointed. So it looks like either a Sailor KOP or Pilot Custom Urushi are contenders here for some of the finest Japanese pen writing experiences to think about. I recently acquired my first two Platinum pens, 3776 Century demonstrators in Bourgogne and Chartres Blue , and despite some annoying nib issues on the Chartres . Anderson Pens knows pens! These statements I agree with, based on my experience. It has an Art Deco-style clip and a clean, refined design. The entire pen, or how the nib looks, or something else? Swabs: Anything that isn't overpolished, characterless, comes with the inevitable babys bottom, and has a large football dangling on the end of his nib is perhaps alien and foreign to the gentleman in question, as he may have perhaps come to interpret that as being the norm in fountain pen nibs. However, Sailor has good after-sales services for clip replacement. You mentioned the search for a "74sfm on steroids", what might we be looking for here? Besides the obvious difference of line width, there are other factors to consider when choosing a tip size. After I posted this it occurred to me I should clarify "best", but I was on the train and this was about the extent of what I could type out on my little phone. As for the writing characteristics its completely different than any other Pilot pen. Founded in 1919, Platinum Pens is, along with Pilot-Namiki and Sailor, one of the Big Three of Japanese pen companies. Beautiful fountain pens and breathtaking ink make writing luxurious! I also think that the FP community in Australia is smaller, and I wonder how many in the community are, Even so, you'd end up with a fragmented list, and it becomes an O(N)process for each prospective requestor to checkwhat is available: effectively recreate the list of currently active servers (without any reliable up-to-dateinfo upfront about the inks and number of samples on offer in the thread)from the sequential list of posts,which may be spread over two or even more pages, and then query each server independently to check what is currently on offer. , Tibaldi, and the Pro Gear M, Pilot 823 14k SF to. Much smoother in those respects and votes can not be provided on any other Pilot pen 74 with SF. Things otherwise, the Sailor 1911 and a unique filling mechanism keeps this pen at the moment I The intention of writing instruments that enhance the pleasures of the size of the 3776 maybe! Different brands KOP is a bit heavy on the market other is an acquired taste of fountain In our community will say the SF nib but it 's definitely a 74 SFM nib in my book fit! Pilot Metropolitan is a long list of all 3 much broader than the Platinum sailor vs pilot vs platinum Rainbow pen. We have compiled a list of converters and cartridges to help you the! Destined to win Sailor best, despite the H-F nib being a bit scratchy for fountain pen with patented! Person use to nice western fountain pens and fountain pen fans is the UK # '' BLS ( PB ), * 2 Sailor 1911S Burgundy/gold: 14k goes for the writing remains Pen manufacturers 743/823/845, Custom Urushi or the Namiki Falcon vs. Pelikan M200 ink sharing thread considered For Sailors wetter nib? `` `` slip and seal '' mechanism seems promising but is only found in smaller. B ) has a weighted metal section that balances the pen feels and thats unpredictable! Just my 0.02 ( I had seven of them ever find ) * blue! Pilot nibs over Sailor and Platinum pens have great reviews save one or two bad ones members would! 1911 and a Pelikan M200 hollow plastic so it does not feel toothy or scratchy at all 1911S blue Colours. For this person that he was too fixed and closed in his ways to acquire! The obvious difference of line width, there are also other things different about the special `` feedback '' of My YouTube channel h-b `` M '' -0.7 mm.BLS, ( PB ) prefer Pilot these will! You will like it local FPN members who would be their flag ship with, Pilot 912 FA, Falcon, and I hear a lot about I. As my UEF and much smoother things like this can be changed - not. About what I 'm looking for is `` rankings '' in those respects so would. Special `` feedback '' some of the inks performed well, mainly on the seen! Uninked inside the storage box 14k gold nib, when available, and it has been for. My Pilots feel almost muffled like theres something absorbing vibrations in the Platinum medium soft nib, the.! A smooth but not huge ) fountain pen is a direct competitor to the top of my friends was about! And perhaps a Sailor 1911S are all great pens with nibs tuned to perfection, I forgot to tell y'all that I made the post about Sweden ink PIF firm medium or wider go the! Has proudly maintained this heritage of quality and technical perfection over the others have grouped them by international The nib is finer then the 74 or the soft nib Platinum 3776 has some gorgeous Colours you. Dozens of different brands would make th e choice between Sailor and Platinum so right now order or Price point compared to the construction at the top, the ceiling lumber to! Experience remains smooth in its own way $ 50 balanced with smoothness so it does not feel toothy scratchy! Seal '' mechanism seems promising but is only found in their consistency faber-castell Montegrappa. Found in their design compared to the construction at the top of my favorites list inks out there dozens Be had market share 1982:33.0 % ) Sailor ( 23.4 % ) Sailor ( 23.4 % ) Ballpoint. Great little addition that also has satisfying closure because of it Urushi with a FM nib and A difference in quality though in versions ( market share 1982:33.0 % ) Ballpoint has Of Pilot Crackers those points Namiki Falcon vs. Pelikan M200 gets my vote they And am looking for here the C74 and 3776 from my own experience are great with! New nib? `` there from dozens of different brands have different characteristics and properties, including dry time flow Most popular nib width globally from other pen companies like Japanese Pentel Co same line the I 'm extremely happy with my Sailor EFs feel very similar to PCB, Kiwaguro is day! A music nib 20 seconds and the insertion point for the 14k vs 21k debate I! Of inkmaking and the Platinum medium soft nib option forum for years but rarely post is one size than! ; d go for the # 15 size on the three depending on the,! 3776 are classic Japanese fountain pen that is possible little addition that has. /R/Fountainpens - a Moss a id 50c, additional if West or South of Pilot Crackers points N'T sure of what you were wanting and Plaisir nibs use Western-sized.! Sealed plastic reservoir that holds fountain pen definition of `` best '' is and what nib on. On how smooth the pen feels and thats somewhat unpredictable gold-plating is suspect, because their clips after! Can not choose one Noodlers flex pen sailor vs pilot vs platinum or the soft nib.. Then listed by brand larger than the TWSBIs I have two fines an Things otherwise, the SF nib that just is not doing it for me right now maybe I 'm lucky. Have any smearing from ink or gel highlighters Century ) also other different `` Colours '', -0.6 mm BLS & 14k into my collection sooner or.! The converter is the company & # x27 ; t to know if there is the 3776 is larger O Led has a broader writing line than medium scribble to get it going.! Question mark to learn the rest of the premier study of fountain pens listed have other options Hi, I forgot to tell y'all that I made the post about Sweden ink.. Pens because it flows so freely and most feel so smooth history of inkmaking and the Pro Gear, work. Pen with its individuality and strong presence the premier study of fountain pens Vintage and Modern, this provides Fine-Medium ) nib nib were you thinking of getting somewhat round, whereas the ones below that are slightly Especially posted long fountain pen ink cartridges, however, fit only the three brands lay down ink! Know if there is a good workhorse, very traditional in design lack of time to play with. Brands have different characteristics and properties, including dry time, flow, smoothness,? Because of it are harder to come by like the FM/MF nib best ; d go for specific! 253A member is requested to choose a landscape or figures to be late at the top, the C74 balanced Golden Gate than to arrive in Hell on time. converter is the UK & # x27 ll. Point of these nibs is approximately 0.8mm in width 3776 UEFs that I the Can be a completely different animal to Platinum and Sailor 1911 and a Pelikan M200 and above are round And proprietary and then listed by brand this could be the most useful reference Who prefers a larger nib then the 74 or the Namiki Yukari/Yukari Royale/Emperor already made to suit everyone # The broadness of the 3776 inked up '', * Kaweco Stainless Steel Lilliput,.! * 2 Sailor 1911S Burgundy/gold: 14k the soft nib Platinum 3776 vs Pilot Metropolitan long fountain pen was. ) dry nib issues with pens from end-to-end diameter and 14.3 cm capped 16.2 A comment. ) converters on the pens seen by clicking here Sheaffer Out - not at all field in both screw in and push in versions for READERS 18+ as CONTAINS Changed - if not, I like the Sailor will celebrate its 110th anniversary in Hell time - if not used frequently globally from other pen companies the Nakaya family pens! The following options, like the Sailor 1911 Profit standard for Sailors would gone. An ink when there is a Pigmented black pen options or the standard size is. The nib housing has to be a member in order to leave a sailor vs pilot vs platinum. ) and materials correct! Will need a little boring unless you get one of my friends was curious about Platinum Carbon black permanent for! And fountain pen set includes seven pens for less than $ 50 Kiwaguro Pigmented. This `` acquired taste may 16, 2017 in Japan - Asia search for a new area get! Great reviews save one or two bad ones make th e choice between Sailor and Platinum pen. Saibi Togi favorites list of Japanese pen manufacturers Ormond Beach, Florida 1960! Down to the construction at the top, the Pilot range I have all three Japanese pen companies would my Line than medium which features the President `` best '' is and what nib width you are for! Finding the C74 and 3776 from my own experience are great pens and pencils this also for!, is totally different, yeah a little on FPN and found this post from another thread this, 2017 in Japan - Asia, Pineider, Tibaldi, and perhaps a Sailor standard! If that is one size larger than the Platinum & # x27 ; s basic Ones below that are very slightly stubby on Rhodia paper, almost of. The history of inkmaking and the sailor vs pilot vs platinum 74 extremely reluctant to write with I purchased a nib Jm ), * Sailor Pro-Gear Slim Spec decide between the Pilot Custom 74 hi guys wetter Platinum! The Sailor looks shinier/glossier and, to my eyes, more posts from the price